Re: [ga] Re: [governance] Establishment of the European Regional At-Large Organizaton

[Danny Younger <dannyyounger@xxxxxxxxx>]

Vittorio,

We have a proactive obligation to prevent capture. 
You may wish to recall the words of the White Paper:

"Governance. The organizing documents (Charter,
Bylaws, etc.) should provide that the new corporation
is governed on the basis of a sound and transparent
decision-making process, which protects against
capture by a self-interested faction, and which
provides for robust, professional management of the
new corporation."

You have chosen to acquiesce to capture because it
serves your interests -- sorry, but I find this to be
repugnant. 

As an ISOC chapter member, I support initiatives that
promote our common stake in maintaining the viability
and global scaling of the Internet, but I do not
support fraud.  ISOC chapters have a place within
ICANN as constituent members of the non-commercial
constituency (NCUC) -- they are not, and have never
claimed to be, voices that speak for the broader
at-large community.

When ICANN staff negotiated a 7% annual increase in
.com fees did we hear an expression of rage from the
ISOC chapters?  No.  We heard nothing.  Not a peep.  

They are not the At-Large -- They don't represent the
At-Large nor are they motivated by the same set of
concerns that impact the real At-Large community --
they are a different body with a different set of
interests and concerns.  In fact, in the last three
and a half years not one single ISOC chapter
functioning as one your At-Large "structures" has ever
sent even one single comment to the ICANN Board on any
at-large topic whatsoever.

Vittorio, this fraud must end.




--- Vittorio Bertola <vb@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> Danny Younger ha scritto:
> > Vittorio,
> > 
> > This European Regional At-Large Organization that
> you
> > are building needs a better name... perhaps you
> can
> > call it EU ISOC & Friends as it is completely
> captured
> > by ISOC (with seven out of its eight structures
> being
> > ISOC chapters).
> 
> The funny thing is that, more or less at the same
> time, I've received a 
> message from an officer of an ISOC chapter, saying
> "why is ICANN doing 
> this - we don't need the At Large, it should be the
> European council of 
> ISOC chapters to do this".
> 
> The truth is that we are trying to create an open
> mechanism where 
> everyone - ISOC chapters, other organizations, and
> individuals - can 
> participate. If only certain kinds of organizations
> use it, then of 
> course they will dominate the mechanism; but, once
> the gates are open, 
> the fault of this only lies with those who don't
> bother to participate.
> -- 
> vb.             [Vittorio Bertola - v.bertola [a]
> bertola.eu.org]<-----
> http://bertola.eu.org/  <- Prima o poi...
> 


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com