Re: [registrars] Fwd: ICANN Issues Advisory Regarding the Inter-Registrar Transfer Policy

[Paul Goldstone <paulg@xxxxxxxxxxxx>]

The advisory is new so I understand why it's not been corrected yet, 
but we just received this:

================================================================
Dear Domain-it, Inc.,

RegistrarX instructed the registry not to transfer the domain name 
registration to your registrar because the domain name, DomainX.COM, 
did not meet the registrar change criteria.

Specifically, the domain name registration did not meet the criteria because:

The domain cannot be transferred to another registrar for a period of 
60 days following a change in Primary Contact or WHOIS Admin Contact.

If you have any questions please contact Customer Service at xxxxxxxx.

Sincerely,

RegistrarX Customer Support
================================================================

According to my support department, the only "change in Primary 
Contact or WHOIS Admin Contact" was turning off whois privacy by the 
registrant to facilitate the transfer.

Not to go on, but we'll be glad to be done with this hurdle in 
registrar transfers.  It's a pain for registrants and it's a pain for 
registrars.

Regards,

~Paul
:DomainIt


At 07:21 PM 4/3/2008, Paul Goldstone wrote:

>FYI...
>
>"
>
>ICANN determined that sufficient confusion exists to warrant the 
>issuance of an advisory to assist registrars in understanding that 
>under the Transfer Policy:
>
>1. Registrars are prohibited from denying a domain name transfer 
>request based on non-payment of fees for pending or future 
>registration periods during the Auto-Renew Grace Period; and
>
>2. A registrant change to Whois information is not a valid basis for 
>denying a transfer request.
>
>"
>
>I'm glad that's been clarified, although I suppose "A registrant change 
>to Whois information" could be interpreted to mean that an 
>Administrative, Billing, Technical or Name Server change doesn't fall 
>under the same rule.  :/
>
>I wonder why they didn't just say "Any change to whois information", 
>or specify exactly what changes they're referring to.
>
>~Paul
>:DomainIt
>
>
>>ICANN
>>
>>http://www.icann.org/
>>
>>News Alert
>>
>>http://www.icann.org/announcements/announcement-03apr08.htm
>>
>>________________________________
>>
>>ICANN Issues Advisory Regarding the Inter-Registrar Transfer Policy
>>
>>3 April 2008 
>>
>>Advisory available at http://www.icann.org/announcements/advisory-03apr08.htm
>>
>>Due to perceived confusion within the registrar community concerning the circumstances under which registrars may validly deny transfer requests pursuant to the Inter-Registrar Transfer Policy, on 19 September 2007, ICANN issued a Notice of Intent to Issue Advisory Regarding the Inter-Registrar Transfer (Notice) http://www.icann.org/announcements/announcement-19sep07.htm.
>>
>>As part of this Notice, ICANN published a Proposed Advisory Regarding the Inter-Registrar Transfer Policy (Proposed Advisory). The purpose of the Proposed Advisory was to solicit comments regarding whether it was necessary to publish an advisory to assist ICANN-accredited registrars in understanding their obligations under the Inter-Registrar Transfer Policy. 
>>
>>The community was informed that comments would be accepted for 30 days regarding the Proposed Advisory. ICANN received 16 comments, of which 14 were supportive of ICANN issuing the Proposed Advisory, one comment opposed the issuance of the Proposed Advisory and one comment was deemed neutral as it did not indicate support or opposition. After considering the comments received and other information provided by registrars regarding the Proposed Advisory, ICANN determined that sufficient confusion exists to warrant the issuance of an advisory to assist registrars in understanding that under the Transfer Policy:
>>
>>1. Registrars are prohibited from denying a domain name transfer request based on non-payment of fees for pending or future registration periods during the Auto-Renew Grace Period; and
>>
>>2. A registrant change to Whois information is not a valid basis for denying a transfer request. 
>>
>>The Advisory [ http://www.icann.org/announcements/advisory-03apr08.htm ] is identical to the Proposed Advisory issued on 19 September 2007, except the term "registration period after expiration" was replaced with "Auto-Renew Grace Period" wherever it appeared in the Proposed Advisory. 
>>
>>Developed through ICANN?s consensus policy process, the Transfer Policy was approved unanimously by ICANN?s Generic Names Supporting Organization (GNSO) and its Board of Directors. After consultation with several interested parties, the Transfer Policy was adopted in 2004. The Transfer Policy provides domain name holders with a standardized process for transferring their domain names from one ICANN-accredited registrar to another upon request. All ICANN-accredited registrars and unsponsored gTLD registry operators are required to comply with the Transfer Policy pursuant to their agreements with ICANN. The purpose of the Advisory is to provide clarity and promote consistent handling of transfer requests. 
>>________________________________
>>
>>Sign up for ICANN's Monthly Magazine http://www.icann.org/magazine/
>> 
>>
>>This message was sent by: ICANN, 4676 Admiralty Way, Suite 330
>>, Marina del Rey, CA 90292-6601
>>
>>Powered by iContact: http://freetrial.icontact.com