Re: [council] Re: Regarding issues report on IDNs from PAF
I agree that it would be a useful objective for the GNSO Council to
coordinate the explanation of the political issues and the requirements.
I do, however, continue to think that this should not be done in
isolation by the council as it needs to take into account a larger
context. I also do not believe that it should be done in a technical
vacuum, but should be done together with the technical experts, from
both the IAB, IETF and elsewhere.
On 5 feb 2006, at 14.57, Avri Doria wrote:
Begin forwarded message:
From: Patrik Fältström <paf@xxxxxxxxx>
Date: 5 februari 2006 14.17.16 EST
To: Avri Doria <avri@xxxxxxx>
Cc: GNSO Council <council@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, John Klensin <john-
ietf@xxxxxxx>, Cary Karp <email@example.com>
Subject: Re: [council] Re: Regarding issues report on IDNs
On 5 feb 2006, at 19.33, Avri Doria wrote:
Even the questions that PAF asks are dependent on the current
thinking about the technology and if there was creative work
being on the research and engineering for IDN, we might have
different questions to answer.
(I know my messages are not accepted by the GNSO mailing list
exploder, but please forward if you want to.)
If you start with the questions you want to ask, and some
requirements, I can let you know what the technology say about it.
For example, wether you want (technical) guarantees that the same
registrant have the domain name example.foo and example.<idn-
version-of-foo>. Or is it a requirement that those two domains can
be managed by two different registrants?
As long as that is not resolved, there is simply no way technical
community can help.
Unfortunately, as interesting as the IAB draft is, it doesn't, to
my mind, do much to indicate what work will be done to try and
figure out solutions, maybe even creative solutions, that take
the very real political realities into account.
Can you please list what those "very real politicla realities"
are? If you do, I can make sure the technical community do have a
look at it. This is exactly what I talk about when I ask for what
questions you have and what the answer is.