Re: [ga] New mailing list: icann-people.

[Leah G <jandl@xxxxxxxxx>]

Thomas Roessler wrote:

> Folks,
>
> I feel that the ICANN community is currently lacking a place for
> reasonable online discussion -- all there is is icannwatch and a
> couple of blogs; the GA list seems mostly dead.  As an experiment,
> I've set up a moderated mailing list named icann-people; please join
> at <http://lists.does-not-exist.org/mailman/listinfo/icann-people>.
>
> I'll run the list the autocratic way: No message is distributed
> unless I, personally, believe it is appropriate, and reasonably
> relevant to the ICANN community.  I'm specifically *not* doing this
> wearing *any* hat but "too long-time ICANN participant."
>
> When (if?) enough people have come together, I'll send an initial
> posting to let subscribers know.
>
> (As I said, this is an experiment.  It may quite well fail.)

Why would people wish to waste time posting to a list where a single 
autocratic list-owner would probably reject or discard messages based on 
personal bias?  The list would have no value to the community at large 
under those conditions.  What gives any individual the reasonable 
authority to decide what is relevant to the ICANN community?

Good luck with your experimant, Thomas.  I, for one, don't have time to 
waste, but I'm sure you'll have ICANN proponants and personal supporters 
join.  It should be a nice, quiet personable list where people of like 
mind collude to exclude dissent and free thinking, not to mention free 
speech.

Regards,

Leah


--
Leah G.
http://forums.delphiforums.com/atlargeorg
http://forums.delphiforums.com/domainwatch