RE: [registrars] Cape town agenda

[Tim Ruiz <tim@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

Just to clarify my concerns regarding the ADD Grace Period and why I
would like to see it as an agenda item for Cape Town.

Right now it is possible for any registrar to register hundreds,
thousands, and even tens of thousands of domain names on a daily basis
and delete the worthless ones within the ADD Grace Period.

For example, it appears that ItsYourDomain.com (Innerwise) or one of
their clients may be doing that quite regularly. Although I don't know
why they are doing it, one reason a registrar (or registrar client) may
want to do that is to take a 3 or 4 day look at the traffic and decide
which ones are worth keeping. Note that it is next to impossible for
this to happen without at least the knowledge, and probably the
assistance, of the registrar.

A review of the registries agreements with ICANN, our RAA, and our
agreements with the registries indicate that there is nothing that can
be enforced to prevent this.

The question for us is, do we think that this is acceptable or is it an
abuse of the ADD Grace Period? If a large number of registrars decided
to participate in this activity it may:

1. Erode consumer confidence in our industry. Domains are reported as
not available, then they are registered after that by another party.

2. Use registry resources for the gain of a very small group of
consumers (speculators).

3. Consume registry bandwidth to the point where registrars' normal
business activity is throttled.

I would like to see us discuss possible solutions amongst ourselves and
with the registries. If our two constituencies can agree on a solution,
I would see no reason why ICANN would not approve.

Tim

 
-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Re: [registrars] Cape town agenda
From: "Marcus Faure" <faure@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Tue, October 19, 2004 2:51 am
To: "Bhavin Turakhia" <bhavin.t@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Cc: "'Registrars List'" <Registrars@xxxxxxxx>

Hi,

i already sent an eMail to the list asking for the addition of:

* Using IANA IDs on registry level

This could be a subitem of transfers.

Yours,
Marcus




> 
> Hi all
> 
> Bob connelly had submitted a below tentative agenda and it is important that
> all of you see if you want any other items, or any specific people to be
> involved in the meetings process and post them to the list immediately -
> 
> --Registrar Constituency meeting processes and email list management (closed
> meeting - constituency members only)
> 
> --Constituency Budget (Donna)(closed meeting - constituency members only)
> 
> --ICANN Budget (BAG and ICANN staff)
> 
> --ICANN positions - process and timing for filling them (ICANN staff)
> 
> --Transfers (TAG)
> 
> --Whois (task force reps)
> 
> --US Congress (GAO) Study on Whois Accuracy (Elana)
> 
> --Net Registry - rules for rebidding (ICANN staff)
> 
> --sTLDs - (ICANN staff) (sTLD applicants invited to present)
> 
> --Process for choosing new gTLDs (may want to discuss separately from
> registries meeting)
> 
> --Meeting with ccNSO (proposed agenda)
> ICANN Budget
> IDNs                    
> .eu presentation (eu ccTLD manager)
> 
> --Meeting with the Registry Constituency (proposed agenda)
> EPP Progress/Concerns 
> Transfers 
> Registry Maintenance Alerts & Notifications 
> ICANN Budget Issues (if still relevant) 
> Global Acceptance of new TLDs
> Evaluation of current TLDs
> Redemptions, and the old idea of not billing us until the end of the
> grace period
> Briefing by registries of any new services they plan to roll out
> 
> --Meeting with the Business/IPC Constituencies (proposed agenda)
> ICANN Budget
> Whois / Privacy / Accuracy
> ICANN and the WSIS process
> 
> --Meeting with the Non-commercial Constituency (proposed agenda)
> Whois 
> Privacy 
> Accuracy
> 
> Best Regards
> Bhavin Turakhia
> Founder, CEO and Chairman
> DirectI
> --------------------------------------
> http://www.directi.com
> Direct Line: +91 (22) 5679 7600
> Direct Fax: +91 (22) 5679 7510
> Board Line (USA): +1 (415) 240 4172
> Board Line (India): +91 (22) 5679 7500
> -------------------------------------- 
>