Re: [council] New generation gTLD Registration Directory Service to replace WHOIS and Motion

[Amr Elsadr <aelsadr@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

Hi Susan, Carlos and all,

On previous discussion of the proposed charter and motion, a concern was raised 
regarding the absence of a rights impact assessment as one of requirements 
listed as part of the phase 1 (and subsequent phases) considerations.

This issue has been repetitively raised by Avri while she was on Council, and 
was also included in the NCSG input to the public comment period for the 
initial report. It was also included in the public comment report prepared by 
staff, but I am having trouble identifying where this was included in the 
proposed charter.

My thoughts on this are that, similar to the “Benefit Analysis” and “Risk 
Assessment” requirements listed under phase 1 deliberations, a rights impact 
assessment be included to involve identification of a rights impact assessment 
requirements in phase 1 of the PDP, followed by a design in phase 2, and 
guidance on how to proceed in phase 3.

I would appreciate us putting aside a few minutes to discuss this during 
today’s call. I would like to handle this by suggesting an amendment to the 
motion, specifically resolved clause 1, where along with approving the charter, 
a reference to a change in the charter be made to include a bullet under the 
phase 1 deliberations on page 69 saying something to this effect:

“Rights Impact analysis: Have registrants rights that may be affected been 
analyzed and considered?”

I’m not personally a fan of suggested amendments to motions at a late stage 
like this, but this isn’t a new topic. It’s been previously discussed on 
several occasions.

Thanks.

Amr

> On Nov 18, 2015, at 6:45 PM, Carlos Raúl Gutiérrez <crg@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> 
> Dear Susan,
> 
> sorry for my delayed reaction. Some minor edits for clarity have been 
> suggested for the motion (with track control)
> <Motion - next-generation RDS PDP WG Charter - edit 18 October 2015[1].docx>
> 
> Otherwise I gladly second the motion for tomorrow session as well!
> 
> 
> Best regards
> 
> Carlos Raúl Gutiérrez
> _____________________
> 
> email: crg@xxxxxxxxxxx
> Skype: carlos.raulg
> +506 8837 7176 (cel)
> +506 4000 2000 (home)
> +506 2290 3678 (fax)
> _____________________
> Apartado 1571-1000
> San Jose, COSTA RICA
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
>> On Nov 4, 2015, at 1:45 PM, Susan Kawaguchi <susank@xxxxxx> wrote:
>> 
>> <Motion - next-generation RDS PDP WG Charter - 2 October 2015[1].docx>
>