RE: [council] GNSO Council letter to the GAC

["Terry L Davis, P.E." <tdavis2@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Stephane

 

Excellent, I can find no further suggestions to offer.  I do like Edmon?s
wording also as you included it in the draft.

 

There may be some value to Appendix Avri suggested; but then again it would
make it feel more like a document than a letter of response.

 

Take care

Terry

 

From: owner-council@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:owner-council@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx] On
Behalf Of Stéphane Van Gelder
Sent: Tuesday, May 12, 2009 7:06 AM
To: Council GNSO
Subject: Re: [council] GNSO Council letter to the GAC

 

Following on, for clarity here is the draft modified to take Edmon?s
comments into account.

Stéphane


Le 12/05/09 15:51, « Stéphane Van Gelder » <stephane.vangelder@xxxxxxxxx> a
écrit :

Edmon,

Ì think that is a very useful suggestion, thank you. As the clock is
running, I am copying this to the Council list.

I am fine with you edit and will amend the draft accordingly unless anyone
objects.

Thanks,

Stéphane


Le 12/05/09 12:25, « Edmon Chung » <edmon@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> a écrit :

sorry for the late response... I do see that the 48 hr clock started
clicking so did not want to send this to the council list unless you feel
comfortable about it...
 
you had: " No such restrictions are imposed on existing gTLD registries and
we feel it would be
inappropriate to attempt to use the new gTLD program to introduce new
contractual
obligations previously not requested or deemed necessary."
 
I don't think that is entirely true... in our contract and in all the ones
in the s round, there is a clause:
" All geographic and geopolitical names contained in the ISO 3166-1 list
from time to time shall initially be reserved at both the second level and
at all other levels within the TLD at which the Registry Operator provides
for registrations. All names shall be reserved both in English and in all
related official languages as may be directed by ICANN or the GAC."
 
What this effectively means is that registries have had to use the other ISO
lists previously already to produce the  "reserved both in English and in
all related official languages" part.
 
Then of course there is the other part in the agreement that says:
"In addition, Registry Operator shall reserve names of territories, distinct
geographic locations, and other geographic and geopolitical names as ICANN
may direct from time to time."
 
Would like to suggest edits as follows:
 
Restrictions are already imposed on existing gTLD registries in this regard,
especially with regards to those adopted for the sTLD round of gTLDs.  We
feel that current contractual obligations are already appropriate and new
contractual obligations maybe unnecessary.
 
 
Edmon
 
 
 
 
 

From: owner-council@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:owner-council@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx] On
Behalf Of Stéphane Van Gelder
Sent: Tuesday, May 12, 2009 4:12 PM
To: Council GNSO
Subject: [council] GNSO Council letter to the GAC

Dear all,

In a letter dated April 24 2009, GAC Chair Janis Karklins wrote to ICANN CEO
Paul Twomey on the subject of geographical names and the new gTLD process.

At our Council meeting last week, it was decided that we should respond to
this letter and I volunteered to write a draft. We agreed that our response
should be sent to the GAC asap, preferably by the end of this week, and Avri
informed the GAC that they should expect a response from the GNSO Council by
this Friday.

In order to fine-tune our draft response, a team was set up and I submitted
my draft to the team yesterday.

The team responded very quickly in order to meet the Council?s Friday
deadline and considered my draft ?good to go?, with one addition by David
Maher and a comment by Avri, both of which have been included in the draft
letter we are submitting to the full Council today (see attached).

Could you please review and let me know of any further changes you would
like to make, or of your approval, so that Avri may then send the finished
letter to the GAC on Friday.

My thanks to the members of the drafting team: David Maher - Avri Doria -
Nacho Amadoz - Edmon Chung - Brian Cute - Ken Stubbs - Olga Cavalli  - Tony
Harris - Terry Davis ? William Drake.

Best,

Stéphane Van Gelder