Re: [council] Issues Report on Domain Tasting

[Ross Rader <ross@xxxxxxxxxx>]

Maria Farrell wrote:
> Dear Council members,
>  
> Attached is the Issues Report on Domain Name Tasting requested by the 
> At-Large Advisory Committee on 9 
> May (http://gnso.icann.org/mailing-lists/archives/council/msg03474.html).
>  
> Best regards,
>  
> Maria Farrell
As a backgrounder, this document is very useful. Thank you very much.

I would like to better understand what the policy implications are 
however. As contrast, when we voted to initiated the Transfers PDP, we 
understood that domain name portability was desirable, and that policy 
action was required to preserve and augment domain name portability. We 
are able to measure the success of that policy development process by 
examining the degree to which domain name portability has been preserved 
and enhanced.
However, after reading this document, I do not understand what the 
policy implications are related to domain tasting. Is this an 
availability issue? An economic one? Are there privacy implications? 
Intellectual property concerns? Before I can vote to proceed with a PDP 
on this subject, I would like to reasonably understand what the 
objectives and drivers are, but unfortunately, this issues report 
doesn't really give me enough of a sense of the issues to guess at what 
the policy outcomes might look like.
-ross