Re: [ga] A Root with a view...

[Karl Auerbach <karl@xxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Stephane Bortzmeyer wrote:
> I cannot find another report about the TLDs most often queried at a
> root name server. Other reports I've seen aggregated data, while this
> small glimpse, however partial, at least *names* the TLDs.
>
> It has been said sometimes that dummy (sorry, Karl, "boutique" TLDs)
> were present in requests to the root name servers. This is clearly
> false, all the non-existing TLDs queried are local domains (such as
> Apple's ".local"), leaking through a configuration error.

(A lot of "boutique" TLDs are pretty dumb, so "dummy" isn't all that bad 
of a description - there's also a lot of really silly "boutique" 
products out there too.)

When I mention that the roots get the full DNS name, it's not intended 
to be a comment on whether 'boutique' TLDs reach the roots or not.  I 
agree with you that such TLDs are often done via a local addition to a 
local resolver and not via a root at all and that if that local resolver 
leaks to a root then something is mis configured.

My comment on roots seeing full DNS names is simply that if and when a 
query gets through the gauntlet of caches and resolvers - and DNS 
performance depends on relatively few doing so - in those cases the full 
DNS "question" (i.e. the DNS name being queried) is usually present in 
its entirety.

        --karl--