Voting Population (27)

Whois Task Force 1, 2, and 3 members

(Each person had only one vote, even though they were members of more than one task force )

1. David Fares
2. David Maher
3. Jeff Neuman
4. Antonio Harris
5. Milton Mueller
6. Paul Stahura
7. Jeremy Banks
8. John Wolfe
9. Thomas Roessler
10. Wendy Seltzer
11. Amadeu Abril i Abril
12. Marilyn Cade
13. Jordyn Buchanan
14. Maggie Mansourkia
15. Kathryn Kleinman
16. Tom Keller
17. Steve Metalitz
18. Niklas Lagergren
19. Sarah Deutsch
20. Ken Stubbs
21. Greg Ruth
22. Frannie Wellings
23. Ross Rader
24. Brian Darville
25. Terry Clark
26. Kiyoshi Tsuru
27. Vittorio Bertola

23 out of 27 task force members voted

Results:

• 16 in favour of retaining MP3 recordings of the task force teleconferences.
• 6 against making MP3 recordings of the task force teleconferences.

• 13 in favour of publishing the recordings on the GNSO website
• 4 against publishing the recordings on the GNSO website

• 1 abstention

Results per task force:

Task Force 1

Restricting access to WHOIS data for marketing

David Fares, David Maher, Jeff Neuman, Antonio Harris, Milton Mueller, Paul Stahura, Jeremy Banks, John Wolfe, Wendy Seltzer

• 3 in favour of retaining MP3 recordings of the task force teleconferences.
• 4 against retaining MP3 recordings of the task force teleconferences.

• 3 in favour of publishing the recordings on the GNSO website
• 1 against publishing the recordings on the GNSO website
  (1 against making MP3 recordings of the task force teleconferences replied to "against" publishing the recordings on the GNSO website)

• 1 abstention

---

Task Force 2

Review of data collected and displayed

Marilyn Cade, Jordyn Buchanan, Maggie Mansourkia, Kathryn Kleinman, Tom Keller, Steve Metalitz, Niklas Lagergren, Thomas Roessler

• 7 in favour of retaining MP3 recordings of the task force teleconferences.
• 1 against retaining MP3 recordings of the task force teleconferences.

• 6 in favour of publishing the recordings on the GNSO website
• 1 against publishing the recordings on the GNSO website

---

Task Force 3

Improving Accuracy of collected data

Sarah Deutsch, Ken Stubbs, Greg Ruth, Francesca (Frannie) Wellings, Ross Rader, Brian Darville, Terry Clark, Kiyoshi Tsuru, Vittorio Bertola

• 6 in favour of retaining MP3 recordings of the task force teleconferences.
• 1 against retaining MP3 recordings of the task force teleconferences.

• 4 in favour of publishing the recordings on the GNSO website
• 2 against publishing the recordings on the GNSO website

---

Ballot sent to each task force member.

A vote on the MP3 issue was proposed during the WHOIS task force 3 call, Wednesday 7 January, 2004.

In consultation with the Task Force 1 and 2 Chairs, Jeff Neuman and Jordyn Buchanan, the same procedure was suggested for Task Force 1 and 2.

Please reply putting a cross next to your choice:

1. Should the WHOIS Task Force 2 MP3 recordings be retained?

   YES [ ]
   NO [ ]

2. If the response to 1. is "yes", should they be published on the gnso.icann.org website?

   YES [ ]
   NO [ ]

GNSO Secretariat